Verdusk's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[The forgotten journey.]

This is great. From the solemn first part, to the kickass second part with a fitting "let's do this" transition. I particularly like the instrumentation in the 2nd part. Only minor quibble would be that the 2nd part seems to get a bit repetitive, as the chord progression and guitar melody seems to remain exactly the same for the whole ~2 minutes.

[Rebirth, Revelation, Retribution]

As a fan of villain themes, I like the scheme theme in this one. My impression is that the villain is not exactly overtly evil, but a more calm and chill type, while also being clearly shady.
The battle themes have these great electronic melodies, but I feel it could be more intense if they are intended for boss themes (unless they are being intentionally nerfed), and would probably benefit from more dynamics, like having some parts get louder, and possibly more instruments.

The outro is very smooth and appropriately dramatic.

My favorite parts are:
(2:00~2:34)
(4:16~5:15)
(7:20~)

[The ShenFailed Piano Remi]

I haven't listened to the original, but I sure like this music. I don't think it's a fail, although I never listened to the original.

[no synth :(]

This music is boring and repetitive. You should try making it less repetitive. Sorry man, but you really should try harder.

[Emotional Instrumental]

Kinda repetitive even for a loop in my opinion but it is a nice sounding loop like what you attempted. This music would be suitable for a scene in a game, or maybe an art game.